There’s a particular breed of thrill-seeker who finds comfort in the macabre. You know the type — wide awake while the rest of the world sleeps, earbuds in, diving deep into decades-old cold cases, unreliable narrators, and killers who seem too smart to catch. Me … It’s me. I’m that type. It’s the 2AM true crime obsession. The thrill. The dread. The morbid curiosity that keeps you hitting “next episode” when you should be going to bed.
These 8 books — both fiction and non-fiction — replicate that same experience. They’re layered, voice-driven, and built to unspool like your favorite podcast. But like all good true crime, they don’t just tell a story. They ask hard questions, they play with perception, and they’re always two steps ahead of you.
8 Killer Reads
What Lies in the Woods by Kate Alice Marshall
Three girls. One lie. And a secret buried for decades.
Naomi and her two best friends survived a brutal attack in the woods when they were eleven. They identified the man responsible and became local legends as a result. But now, years later, that story is starting to unravel. Marshall spins a sharp, atmospheric thriller that hinges on memory, trauma, and the power of the stories we tell ourselves to survive. Perfect for fans of cold cases, unreliable survivors, and the haunting realization that no one tells the whole truth — not even victims.
True Crime Story by Joseph Knox
A missing university student. A true crime writer who gets too close.
Structured like an investigative podcast transcript, this novel blurs fiction and reality until you’re questioning everything. Joseph Knox weaves in real-world commentary and disturbing redactions to craft a story so convincingly meta, you’ll be Googling names just to be sure it’s not real. It’s unsettling, brilliant, and more than a little unhinged. This is the kind of story that makes you feel complicit just for reading.
Killer Stories by Brin Hodgskiss & Nicole Engelbrecht
Real killers. Real confessions. Real nightmares.
Forget fiction. This is the stuff your favorite podcasts only scratch the surface of. Psychologist Brin Hodgskiss sat face-to-face with South Africa’s most dangerous serial killers, capturing their words, their delusions, and their terrifying rationalizations. Years later, true crime podcaster Nicole Engelbrecht unearthed his recordings, and together they created a chilling, psychologically rich book that goes beyond the headlines. What emerges is a study in narrative psychology, human depravity, and the disturbing similarities between their stories — and ours.
A Flicker in the Dark by Stacy Willingham
Small towns don’t forget their monsters.
Chloe Davis has spent her life outrunning her past, specifically, the fact that her father confessed to murdering six teenage girls when she was just twelve. Now a psychologist, she’s built a carefully controlled life. But when local girls begin disappearing again, the past claws its way back. Willingham creates a Southern gothic atmosphere pulsing with dread, wrapped around a protagonist who may or may not trust herself.
I’ll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara
The real thing is more terrifying than fiction.
Part memoir, part investigation, this book documents Michelle McNamara’s obsessive hunt for the Golden State Killer, a man who eluded authorities for decades. What sets this apart isn’t just the case, but rather the humanity. McNamara’s writing is intimate, insightful, and heartbreaking, capturing the thrill of the chase and the psychological toll it takes. A must-read for anyone who wants to understand the mind of a sleuth, and the monster she’s chasing.
The Appeal by Janice Hallett
Murder hidden between the lines.
Told entirely through emails, texts, and police notes, this novel task the reader with unraveling the mystery behind a death in a small-town drama group. But as the mundane correspondence piles up, something darker starts to emerge. Hallett doesn’t just play with form, she turns the reader into the investigator. It’s as voyeuristic and addictive as eavesdropping on a case file nobody wanted you to see.
My Lovely Wife by Samantha Downing
Suburbia has never been this bloodthirsty …
A married couple bond over the thrill of killing, but this isn’t just a dark fantasy. It’s a chilling examination of appearances, complicity, and the thin veneer of civility. Downing plays with the concept of the “perfect marriage” and twists it into something cold, calculated, and disturbingly seductive. You’ll read this one with morbid glee, questioning how far you’d go for love, and whether you’d even see it coming.
Catch Me a Killer: A Profiler’s True Story by Micki Pistorius
She hunted monsters. Then wrote about them.
As South Africa’s first criminal profiler, Micki Pistorius walked into the minds of killers and emerged with insight most of us hope never to need. From the Station Strangler to the Phoenix Cane Killer, these real-life cases are told with clinical precision and eerie clarity. But this isn’t just about murderers, it’s about the people who catch them, and the darkness they carry away. If Mindhunter is your comfort binge, this is your next obsession, believe me. You can read my review here.
Can’t stop. Won’t sleep. Still pressing play …
Check out some other Book Lists, and make sure to subscribe to Monique’s newsletter so you don’t miss a single post!
