There’s something dangerous about innocence. Not in the obvious, corrupted kind of way, but in that quiet, goosebump-raising sort of sense. The kind that makes you lean in, lower your voice, and second-guess your own instincts. And when it comes to storytelling, nothing draws a reader in more effectively than a character who seems pure… until they’re not.
As writers, we often reach for the dramatic, the wild, the twisted. We think shock value is the ultimate hook. But there’s more power in subtlety. A lot more. Sometimes, the most effective way to sink your claws into a reader is to wrap your story in sugar, lace it with charm, and whisper secrets through a character who seems harmless. That’s the trick. That’s how you lure them in.
Start Soft to Hit Hard
Let’s say you’re writing a psychological thriller or a slow-burning gothic romance. You’ve got tension simmering just under the surface. What’s the fastest way to unsettle your reader? Introduce a character who seems angelic. Maybe it’s a child with a doll and big, glassy eyes. Maybe it’s a woman with a gentle laugh and a fondness for baking. Maybe it’s a man who rescues stray cats and never raises his voice. Give them that soft focus, that idyllic glow, and let the reader fall for it.
Then start turning screws.
When you weaponize innocence, you set up contrast. And contrast is everything in storytelling. The more innocent someone appears, the more jarring it is when they snap. The more polite someone is, the more shocking it is when their lies unravel. Readers love to be fooled, even when they don’t know it. And they love it even more when they look back and realize you left them breadcrumbs the entire time.
Layer Motives with Honey
The trick is not to make your characters perfect. Perfect is boring. Instead, give them believable innocence. Let their kindness feel real. Let their actions be grounded in empathy or survival or love. The neighbor who brings over fresh muffins every week? Maybe she’s genuinely lonely. Maybe her mother told her to be useful to be loved. Maybe she’s been watching you through the curtains since you moved in.
See the difference?
You don’t need your sweet character to be evil. You just need them to be interesting. Readers don’t fall for caricatures. They fall for layered motives. They fall for people who are trying their best… even if “their best” leaves a trail of destruction. And when those motives come coated in sugar, they become that much harder to see — and that much more satisfying to uncover.
That’s the beauty of it. You’re not giving your readers a villain in disguise. You’re giving them a puzzle. And when they realize they were charmed into letting their guard down, that’s when the story starts to linger. That’s when they start flipping back through the pages to find the moment the mask slipped.
Keep the Glow but Twist the Roots
If you’re worried this kind of character won’t work in your genre, don’t be. Innocence isn’t genre-specific. It thrives in crime fiction, horror, romance, fantasy — even dystopian worlds. You just need to anchor it in your setting.
In horror, innocence sharpens the fear. In thrillers, it builds paranoia. In romance, it complicates desire. Even in contemporary fiction, the tension between surface and shadow gives your character more weight, more nuance.
Let’s say your story is set in a small town. Great. Now, give your innocent character a flawless reputation. Everyone loves her. She volunteers, smiles, knows every dog’s name. And then let someone go missing. Suddenly, the sweetness feels off. Suddenly, the reader isn’t so sure anymore. But they want to believe. They want to hold onto that glow.
That push and pull? That’s the good stuff.
Even better, you don’t have to reveal everything. Sometimes, the ambiguity is more chilling than a full confession. Sometimes, leaving the roots of their innocence a little twisted is what gives the story its staying power. Maybe she didn’t do anything wrong. Or maybe she did. But she still brings muffins. She still smiles. And you, as the writer, get to decide how close the reader gets to the truth.
In the End …
Innocence is not weakness. It’s not fragility. It’s a smokescreen. A mirror. A trap. Used intentionally, it can be your story’s most magnetic element. So next time you’re building a character or shaping a narrative, don’t start with rage or revenge. Start with sweetness. Start with vulnerability. Start with someone readers want to trust.
Then start peeling it back.
The best monsters, after all, are the ones that hide in plain sight.
Check out some other Writing Tips, and make sure to subscribe to Monique’s newsletter so you don’t miss a single post!
